Swiss Meringue Buttercream is awesome, but it can be so hard to make.

This is the perfect buttercream icing for piping because, as the name suggests, it contains egg whites. Egg whites are a super strong binding agent that give stability to the buttercream which would otherwise melt or split while inside the piping bag from the warmth of your hands. It’s great for eating because it’s creamy and smooth.

Traditional SMB involves whipping up a thick, fluffy meringue and then adding butter to it at precisely the right temperature, in precisely the right measure and at precisely the right time. It’s tricky because the butter will often deflate the meringue in a matter of seconds, leaving us with a rather disheartening, curdled-looking mess. Most sources say that you can just keep beating the buttercream when this happens and it will magically come together. This is true, but not reliable. And ya know, even if it is true, why put yourself through the emotional strain?

I tried to follow a traditional recipe a few times – it worked well once and also failed horribly once. Out of desperation I googled ‘“foolproof” swiss meringue buttercream’ and came across a recipe from a blogger in the US – it gives a useful scientific explanation of why the traditional method of making SMB is so hit and miss. My understanding is that the fats in the butter cause the aerated egg whites in the meringue to collapse. The butter works much better as an emulsifier with egg whites in syrup form rather than meringue form. For the full write up, see this post on Cake Paper Party – http://www.cakepaperparty.com/2014/04/foolproof-swiss-meringue-buttercream/.

While the ratio is definitely important, it is by no means set in stone – you just need to make sure the amount of egg whites used is equal to at least half the amount of butter (1:2). Extra egg whites don’t hurt but may not be necessary. The original recipe measures egg whites in weight because it uses the already separated version available in cartons. I use fresh eggs, but you can still measure in weight using a scale (or estimate – if an egg is 70g, the egg white is probably around 40g). Again, I have adapted the recipe for quantities available in Australia and changed it to metric measurements. I also added cream of tartar for peace of mind as it is commonly used for stabilising egg whites, reduced the sugar – just add more if you want it sweeter.

It’s important to note that you can do a lot with this buttercream. While this recipe calls for vanilla, I have used things like elderflower cordial, Wizz Fizz and tea to flavour it.

Firstly, make the egg white syrup. Make sure it reaches around 72 degrees. The whites will have technically cooked, but they will be free of salmonella when they reach this temperature. It’s good to be precise, but not essential. I don’t own a cooking thermometer, I usually just wait for the sugar to blend in with the egg whites because this only happens at well above 72 degrees. Also, if you’ve ever done coffee making, you’ll know how to feel for temperature! Once this is done, chuck the bowl in the fridge to cool down, but only to room temperature, so keep checking it.

DSC_0703 DSC_0706

While the syrup is cooling down, whip up the butter til it’s fluffy. I love the look of white buttercream, which is why I try to use a good quality butter. Organic butter is closer to white than yellow. To lighten it further, I used this Wilton white icing colour. It’s also great if you’ve added too much food colouring to something and want to undo it.

DSC_0702 DSC_0711

Once the syrup is at about room temperature, beat it into the butter a little at a time. When it’s all combined the buttercream should be a little sticky and springy. It should ball up slightly and pull away from the side of the bowl.

DSC_0709 DSC_0713

Spread or pipe in your favourite patterns. For this rose pattern, use a star tip (I used Wilton 2D) and pipe in a spiral, starting from the middle going in circles to the edge.

This amount should cover 24 cupcakes.

DSC_0717 DSC_0722 DSC_0743

~ Recipe ~
Ingredients:

  • 6 egg whites (around 240g)
  • 400g butter – softened
  • 300g sugar
  • 1 tsp cream of tartar
  • 0.5 tsp of salt
  • 1 tsp vanilla bean paste

Method:

  1. Place egg whites and sugar into a heatproof bowl along with a thermometer, over a saucepan of boiling water. Make sure the water isn’t touching the bowl above.
  2. Slowly whisk the egg whites and sugar until combined. Keep the syrup over the heat until it reaches around 71-72 degrees. The egg whites have just cooked but still look raw without becoming opaque.
  3.  Take it off the heat and cool to room temp in the fridge. You’ll need to check it every now and then so it doesn’t get too cold.
  4. In a large mixing bowl, beat the butter until light and fluffy.
  5. Once the sugar and egg white syrup has cooled to about room temperature, add a little to the butter and beat until combined. Repeat until all of the syrup is used up.
  6. Add in the salt, cream of tartar and vanilla (or other flavour) then beat for about 1 more minute to lighten the buttercream even more.
  7. Use a spatula to spread onto cake or transfer into piping bag to make your favourite designs/patterns.

12 thoughts on “Cheat’s Swiss Meringue Buttercream

  1. The vanilla flavour really comes through with the bean paste …. you will never use essence again!

  2. This is a fantastic recipe. I too have had success and failure with regular Swiss buttercream but this method makes a lot more sense and seems much more robust. Worked like a charm and super yummy.

    1. Thank you Heather!

      Since trying out this method I’ve learned a few tips and tricks for mastering the the traditional buttercream, and I’d still probably use this one for something quick and failsafe.

      Glad you liked it :)

  3. Heather….
    If I was to use the carton egg whites would I then just add the sugar slowly while beating…?
    Thanks in advance

    1. Hi Olivia,

      If you were to use carton egg whites you can treat them the exact same way! You will still have to heat them with the sugar and make the syrup, and heat it just enough to make them safe to consume. Hope this helps :)

      Tash

  4. Excellent recipe, I used carton egg whites, and half brown/half regular sugar as I wanted the caramel flavours. Came together beautifully, tastes divine and ices like a dream. It’s a keeper that’s for sure!

  5. Hi there. Thanks for sharing this. I was thinking of trying summer stone’s recipe but thought it may be too sweet for me so your adjustments look like they may be more suitable for my taste. I live in Melbourne and would like to know how this holds up in summer. I will be working in an air conditioned room and I need to pipe grass. Will this buttercream hold its shape well enough for that?

    1. Hello!

      I prepared this in summer a number of times and it seemed to be fine! In an air conditioned room you should not have any problems :) Just try to work as quick as you can so it doesn’t melt too much in your hand.

      Hope that helps!

      Tash

      1. Thank you so much Tash. I made the buttercream today and it turned out really tasty and stable. I did however run into a problem: it had lots of small air bubbles all over it. I tried stirring it with a spatula but couldn’t get it to smoothen out. When I cooked the egg & sugar mixture there was a small amount of foam on it. Once it cooled down, I mixed the syrup well before adding it to the butter. So I am wondering whether those air bubbles came from the foam or perhaps I accidentally cooked the egg whites? As for the butter, I whipped till light and fluffy on medium-high speed. I beat the butter till light and fluffy on medium-high first and then slowed it down to low while adding the sugar syrup. I then beat it for a minute or so again on high after adding the vanilla extract. Sorry to bother you again. I’m a newbie to this so any insight from you will be greatly appreciated.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *